How to Fish WikiFor How to Fish 1.1.3
Yummy in my tummy

Yummy in My Tummy Achievement: Eat a Burnt Creature

Overcook any creature on a lit grill until it burns, then eat it; the only real requirement is an unlocked grill.

Steam conditionEat a burnt creature
Players who have it48.3% of players (Steam global, 2026-10-21)
HiddenNo
Added in1.0 (launch, 2026-08-20)

How to burn and eat a creature

You need a working grill first, and that needs the Grillmaster.

  1. Unlock the grill on the Desert island by giving the Grillmaster a whole Blue Shark.
  2. Hold a cheap creature over the lit grill.
  3. Keep cooking past the peak value until it turns burnt.
  4. Eat the burnt creature.

What counts for Yummy in my tummy

Any creature works as long as it is burnt when you eat it. Use something cheap: burning wipes out the value that cooking adds.

Grill not working?

No flame means the grill is still locked; the lighter only comes from the Grillmaster for a whole Blue Shark or Goblin Shark. Lava streams on the Volcano also cook creatures.

Grill achievements in one go

The same grill unlock gives Grillmaster, so do both in one visit.

Share of players from Steam global achievement stats, read on 21 October 2026.